If you are a California employee who has not been furnished with itemized wage statements, contact Astanehe Law today to discuss your options with an experienced California employment attorney. What information should be on a paycheck stub? Most employers in California are subject to both the federal and state minimum wage laws. The aforementioned Labor Code § 226 pay stub & wage statement requirements do not apply to two employee groups: Live-in nannies, au pairs, housekeepers, and other similar employees; and, State, city, county, district, or other government entity employees. State Disability Insurance (SDI) The 2020 SDI withholding rate is 1.0 percent (.01). California employees with wage claims may bring their claim at the DLSE or in court. This Chart provides an overview of the frequency, method of distribution, and content of wage statements required under state law, including whether employers may distribute wage statements … Help with wage income My employer did not send me a W-2 Failure to deliver this accurate wage statement will result in fines, including: Up to $1,000 per employee for failure to provide wage statements allows private […] For employers paying less than minimum wage for nonproductive time, the wage statement must state the total hours of other nonproductive time, the rate of compensation, and the gross wages paid for that time during the pay period. The California Supreme Court recently addressed this issue in two companion cases: Ward v. B256232 (Cal. Wage Statements Existing California law requires every employer, at the time of each payment of wages, to furnish each employee with an accurate statement in writing showing gross wages, hours worked, deduction and other items. All deductions made from wages. The Take Away: Employers must provide California employees with itemized wage statements clearly detailing how their pay is calculated. California's state minimum wage rate is $13.00 per hour.This is greater than the Federal Minimum Wage of $7.25. The California Court of Appeal has held that: (1) the use of payroll service provider generated unique employee file numbers on employee wage statements, in lieu of the employer’s internal employee identification number or last four digits of employee social security numbers, is legally permissible under California law; and (2) employers are not required to state applicable hourly rates … This amount is before the employer makes any deductions. Report your wages when you file your federal return. The Takeaway. See Pay Statement Requirements. State Disability Insurance (SDI) The 2020 SDI withholding rate is 1.0 percent (.01). With a few exceptions, California law requires the following items on a paycheck stub. This means that the minimum salary for exempt employees in California will also be increasing annually. California return. As we’ve discussed, while AB 1506 scales back certain PAGA claims, it doesn’t change what information must be included on every employee’s regular wage statement. Your W-2 also reports the amount of federal, state, and other taxes withheld from your paycheck. In both Ward v. United Airlines, Inc. and Omar v. Delta Airlines, Inc., the Ninth Circuit asked the California Supreme Court to decide a There are penalties for employers not giving paystubs: The 2020 ETT rate is 0.1 percent (.001) on the first $7,000 of each employee’s wages. The rate includes Disability Insurance (DI) and Paid Family Leave (PFL). The California Labor Code also provides for an additional civil penalty for certain violations. What is the minimum wage? In certain circumstances, this may be the right forum. You may have additional claims. Report your wages when you file your federal return. notice and wage statement requirements Like the FFCRA, the new law has a notice requirement, which must be posted at the workplace or distributed electronically to employees who … probably not you). Contact Astanehe law to discuss which forum is right for your California pay stub & wage statement violation claim. A Guide to Minimum Wage Laws in California for Employees. Because wage statement claims are susceptible to class action treatment—and because prevailing class action plaintiffs can recover up to $4,000 in penalties per affected employee (not to mention attorney’s fees)—even technical violations of California’s wage statement requirements can create significant legal exposure. See Employee Notification Requirements. California's state minimum wage rate is $13.00 per hour.This is greater than the Federal Minimum Wage of $7.25. The DLSE is faster, free, and informal. Commentary on Issues Facing California Employers. In California, employees have a legal right (meaning that your business has a legal requirement) to an accurate, itemized wage statement for every processed paycheck. Please contact Astanehe Law for advice on specific legal issues. Total hours worked by a nonexempt, hourly employee; The inclusive dates for the period the employee is paid; The name of the employee and the last four digits of his/her social security number or an employee identification number; All applicable hourly rates in effect during the pay period and the corresponding number of hours worked at each hourly rate; and. The minimum wage applies to most employees in California, with limited exceptions including tipped employees, some student workers, and other exempt occupations.. Soto v. Motel 6 Operating, L.P., 4 Cal. California’s current minimum wage rate is $12.00 for employers with 26 or more employees and $11.00 for employers with 25 or fewer employees.. For more information on California’s minimum wage laws, visit our California Minimum Wage Laws page, which includes topics such as minimum wage, tip minimum wage, tip sharing and pooling, and subminimum wages. Execustaff HR Nov 4, 2020 7:45:00 AM One of the most complicated components of HR administration is compliance. For employees compensated on a piece-rate basis – the worker is paid per unit produced – California pay stubs & wage statements must include the total number of piece-rate units earned and the applicable piece-rate. Existing California law requires every employer, at the time of each payment of wages, to furnish each employee with an accurate statement in writing showing gross wages… Do meal period premiums trigger derivative liability for waiting-time penalties and inaccurate wage statements? The convergence of local, state, and federal laws creates an intense, dynamic, and ever-changing tsunami of regulatory requirements. . California appellate courts have recently offered some relief to employers issuing wage statements that fail to comply with the state’s hyper-technical content requirements. Total hours worked (not required for salaried exempt employees) The number of piece-rate units earned and any applicable piece rate if the employee is paid on a piece rate basis. Most employers don’t spend much time reviewing pay statements, but in California, simple technical violations can be costly. Labor Code section 226.3 provides that an employer who violates Labor Code section 226(a) can face a civil penalty of $250 per employee for each violation in an initial citation and $1,000 per employee for each violation in a subsequent violation where the employer fails to provide the employee with a “wage deduction statement” or does not maintain records, as required by Labor Code section 226(a). Labor Code § 226 (e) (2) (B). 1. App. Wage Statements. A 50-state survey of itemized wage statement (or pay stub or check stub) requirements. The SDI taxable wage limit is $122,909 per employee, per year. The minimum wage applies to most employees in California, with limited exceptions including tipped employees, some student workers, and other exempt occupations.. Labor Code § 226.3. In California, most employers must pay employees their regular wages, with some exceptions, at least twice during each calendar month on the days designated in advance as regular paydays. Additional requirements apply to certain temporary services employees. Ready and willing to accept work immediately. Below are links to essential reporting and payment information for California employers. Under California law, every employer must furnish an accurate itemized wage statement when paying wages. – Requirements of wage statement. Labor Code §§ 226(d), (h). By continuing to browse our website you consent to our use of cookies as set forth in our Cookie Policy. This income will be included in your federal AGI, which you report on your California return. California employees who do not receive pay stubs complying with California law have a wage claim against their employer, entitling them to monetary damages. Like the FFCRA, the new law has a notice requirement, which must be posted at the workplace or distributed electronically to employees who do not frequent the workplace. Gross wages earned. See Employee Notification Requirements. Employers providing unlimited paid sick leave or unlimited paid time off may satisfy this requirement by indicating “unlimited” on the wage statement or employee notice. Employers must provide written notice of certain pay related information to nonexempt employees when they are hired and when the information changes, under the California Wage Theft Prevention Act. At the time the paycheck is issued and for at least 30 days after, sufficient funds or credit in the payroll account must exist for the paycheck’s payment. The employer must provide written notice, either on the wage statement or separate writing given to the employee on payday, setting forth the amount of paid sick leave available, or amount of paid time off leave. California Labor Code Section 226 (a) outlines nine specific items that must be included on a pay statement: Gross wages earned. Help with wage income My employer did not send me a W-2 Employers that ignore these requirements face liability both under section 226(e), and, through PAGA, under section 226.3. One of the requirements of section 226(a) is that the employer state the total number of hours that an employee worked. This decision is good news for California employers, as it prevents what could be a burdensome requirement. This information must be presented in a way that employees can “promptly and easily” determine from the wage statement alone. The law contains immediate notice and posting requirements, which include a poster that must be made available to employees by September 19, 2020, as well as mandatory printing of the amount of available California COVID-19 supplemental paid sick leave balances on employees’ wage statements by the next pay period following September 9, 2020. California employers have frequently been faced with confusing standards for the application of California’s stringent wage statement requirements for employees that routinely travel between states as a function of their jobs. State Wage Notice Requirement (Y/N) Applicable Statutes Requirements Template (Y/N) California Y Section 2810.5 of the Labor Code Employers must provide notice to employees of their rate(s) of pay, designated pay day, the employer's intent to claim allowances as part of the minimum wage, and the Second, other states have no legitimate interest in shielding California-based employers from the requirements of California wage law as to work performed in California. Because wage statement claims are susceptible to class action treatment—and because prevailing class action plaintiffs can recover up to $4,000 in penalties per affected employee (not to mention attorney’s fees)—even technical violations of California’s wage statement requirements can create significant legal exposure. For your consultation, contact Astanehe Law to discuss your options with an experienced California employment law attorney. State, city, county, district, or other government entity employees. Pay period regulations require employers to provide pay stubs semi-monthly or at the time of each payment of wages. See Wage and Hour. San Diego, CA - December 18, 2020 - Wage Statement and Pay Stub requirements differ from state to state and can often have seemingly tedious policies in place for compliance. It might seem like just one more HR headache for California employers but, with the proper guidance, completing the California Wage Notice Form for … Sept. 26, 2019). This guide is designed to assist employers in complying with state and local/city minimum wage requirements. California pay stubs and wage statements must include the employee’s full name and the last four digits of the employee’s social security number or an employee identification number. The pay stub and itemized wage statement must include a separate listing of all deductions made from the gross wages. In California, there are requirements relating to the minimum wage, overtime, meal and rest breaks, breastfeeding breaks and child labor. California has a two-tier minimum wage requirement, depending on the employer’s size. Labor Code §§ 226(d), (h). Employers in California have to meet the minimum wage requirements as required by the California state labor law apart from the Federal requirement. Ct. App. Naranjo et al. Form of Wage Payment. Understanding Wage Statements in California. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Minimum Wage. California Employer’s Guide (DE 44) (PDF) Weekly Benefits Certification Requirements. State Wage Notice Requirement (Y/N) Applicable Statutes Requirements Template (Y/N) California Y Section 2810.5 of the Labor Code Employers must provide notice to employees of their rate(s) of pay, designated pay day, the employer's intent to claim allowances as part of the minimum wage, and the State Minimum Wage. Fox Rothschild Labor & Employment – Practical Advice, e-Book: Guide to San Francisco Employment Laws, e-Book: Doing Business in California: A Guide for the California Employer, May Employers Require Employees to be Vaccinated for COVID-19: The EEOC Weighs In, Important Webinar Invitation: “Understanding Cal/OSHA’s New Emergency COVID-19 Prevention Regulation”, Newly-Released FAQs Aid Employers in Complying with Cal/OSHA Emergency COVID-19 Prevention Regulation, Demanding Cal/OSHA COVID-19 Regulation Set to Become Effective. Employers must provide written notice of certain pay related information to nonexempt employees when they are hired and when the information changes, under the California Wage Theft Prevention Act. These claims are far easier to prevent than they are to resolve. This calculation gives us a monthly salary that is equal to twice the state minimum wage for full-time employment.⁠41. At the time the paycheck is issued and for at least 30 days after, sufficient funds or credit in the payroll account must exist for the paycheck’s payment. Your W-2 also reports the amount of federal, state, and other taxes withheld from your paycheck. . Labor Code § 226 requires that each itemized wage statement include: Copyright: andrewgenn / 123RF Stock Photo. App. The pay stub and itemized wage statement must state net wages earned. By definition, if an employer has erred in wage calculations, it has messed up the earnings statements. Benefits and pitfalls exist to both, and every California employee’s wage claim demands an individual analysis. Net Wages, also known as take-home pay, are gross-pay after subtracting deductions. Employers must adhere to several strict requirements pertaining to itemized wage statements furnished to California employees. Although federal labor law does not require employers to provide pay stubs to employees, California paystub law requires employers give an “itemized wage statement” or paystub for each pay period (a standard pay period is 2 weeks). The piece-rate pay stub and wage statement must include the total hours of compensable rest and recovery breaks, the employees compensation rate, and the gross wages paid for those periods during the pay period. This Chart provides an overview of the frequency, method of distribution, and content of wage statements required under state law, including whether employers may distribute wage statements … Labor Code Section 226 (a) requires an employer to provide a paystub, i.e., “a detachable part of the check, draft or voucher paying the employee’s wage” or separate written document if wages are paid by personal check or … 9 Things You Must Include In Your California Wage Statements, New Developments on Meal Waivers for Healthcare Workers - Back Where We Started, CA Supreme Court Revises Opinion on De Minimis Rule, CA Supreme Court Says Employers Can't Disregard Trivial Amounts of Time. California pay stubs and wage statements must include all applicable hourly rates in effect during the pay period and the corresponding number of hours worked at each hourly rate by the employee. You are entitled to be paid the higher state minimum wage. How to report Federal return. Labor Code § 226(e)(1). For employees paid on a piece-rate basis, the number of piece rate units earned, regardless of time worked. How to report Federal return. © 2020 Astanehe Law || This website includes general information about legal issues and developments in the law. You must be: Physically able to work. California has a minimum wage order that sets the minimum wage. Notice and Wage Statement Requirements. This is a unique website which will require a more modern browser to work! Paydays, pay periods, and the final wages. Although the draconian state law on wage statements often makes it feel like the deck is stacked against the business community, a California Court of Appeals recently provided a rare win for employers when it comes to what information must be provided on the statements. Salaried, or exempt, employees are exempt from this requirement. California Tenants: Click for our Complete Guide to COVID-19 California Tenant Protections, California Employee Coronavirus/COVID-19 Disability Discrimination, California Employee Expense Reimbursement Lawsuit. Minimum Wage. The rate includes Disability Insurance (DI) and Paid Family Leave (PFL). California State Minimum Wage Requirements. Fox Rothschild LLP is a national law firm with 900 attorneys practicing in 27 offices coast to coast. v. Spectrum Security Services, Inc., No. California Law Protects Workers' Rights - Who Knew? The California Supreme Court answered the Ninth Circuit’s questions as follows: (1) The Railway Labor Act exemption in Wage Order No. California employers should take note of the following changes to state and local minimum wage laws—set to take effect on January 1, 2021—that will … Labor Code § 226.3. In two class action cases that have been consolidated in federal court, pilots and flight attendants are alleging, among other things, that their airline employers failed to provide them with compliant wage statements under California law. This penalty may only be imposed by the Labor Commissioner by citation after notice and a hearing opportunity. The amount of gross or net wages paid during the pay period; The total hours worked, if the employee is non-exempt; The number of piece-rate units earned during the pay period, if the employee is paid on a piece-rate basis; An … California pay stubs and wage statements must include the gross (total) wages earned by the employee. On June 3, 2019, a Northern California Federal District Court Judge ordered Walmart to pay nearly $102 million for various wage and hour violations, primarily based on failure to provide wage statements (i.e., pay stubs) that comply with the requirements of California law. “(1) gross wages earned, (2) total hours worked by the employee, . The minimum wage requirement for the California State is $13 per hour for 2020. The employer must establish a regular payday and is required to post a notice that shows the day, time and location of payment. See Pay Statement Requirements. You are entitled to be paid the higher state minimum wage. At the same time, California courts have given the green light to class action lawsuits based on violations of relatively obscure provisions of the state’s Wage Orders. Mandatory items to be listed on a pay stub: Gross wages earned. Minimum wage is the absolute lowest amount of money, usually per hour, that an employer must pay an employee for a job. The Take Away: Employers must provide California employees with itemized wage statements clearly detailing how their pay is calculated. Thus, California’s itemized wage statement provisions do not require an employer to include the monetary value of accrued vacation or PTO on the pay statement merely because it has accrued, but has not been used or paid. No legal advice is intended. The California Supreme Court recently addressed this issue in two companion cases: Ward v. Employers who fail to include the required information are setting themselves up for potential PAGA claims. California has laws that relate to employee pay and benefits, including temporary disability insurance, health care continuation, pay statements, wage deductions and wage notice requirements. 5th 385, 391 (2016). E-file and E-pay Mandate for Employers. Importantly, California’s minimum wage is set to increase every year on January 1 st until 2023. CA Labor Code Section 207 Information on this website may not constitute the most up-to-date legal information. Further, attorney fees are not recoverable at the DLSE and California employees have a shorter statute of limitations. Soto v. Motel 6 Operating, L.P., 4 Cal. The aforementioned Labor Code § 226 pay stub & wage statement requirements do not apply to two employee groups: California employees with wage statement & pay stub claims have the option of filing their action a the DLSE or in court. Currently, large employers–those with 26 or more employees–are required to pay a minimum wage of $13 per hour. Labor Code §§ 226.4, 226.5. California pay stubs and wage statements must state the employee’s total hours worked for the pay period. Available for work. App. Labor Code § 246. Additional requirements apply to certain temporary services employees. Total hours worked by the employee (unless the employee is exempt from OT) Number of piece-rate units earned, if applicable. California law requires that, on public works projects, pay to workers must equal: “the general prevailing rate of per diem wages for work of a similar character in the locality in which the public work is performed, and not less than the general prevailing rate.” The DLSE has issued a "model" Notice for non-food sector workers that can be found here. First, California’s overtime laws apply by their terms to all employment in the state, without reference to the employee’s place of residence. Live-in nannies, au pairs, housekeepers, and other similar employees; and. For temp employees, the statement must include the rate of pay and total hours worked for each temporary service assignment. You can find more detailed information in the California Employer’s Guide . California's New Wage Statement Requirements. We’ve been serving clients for more than a century, and we’ve been climbing the ranks of the nation’s largest firms for many years, according to both The Am Law 100 and The National Law Journal. Nov 4, 2020 7:45:00 AM One of the beginning and the end of the beginning and end... Right forum employers who fail to include the required information are setting themselves up potential. Or exempt, employees are exempt from California pay stub or check stub ).! Other taxes withheld from your paycheck 13.00 per hour.This is greater than federal. 1 pay stubs semi-monthly or at the DLSE is faster, free, and other similar employees ; and entitled. In your federal AGI, which you report on your California return s claim! Employment law attorneys can perform a review of your paystubs and wage statements, discuss your options,,. Is equal to twice the state minimum wage ] Box # 4 is for employers fail! Giving paystubs: Mandatory items to be listed on a paycheck stub you with accurate and lawful paystubs complying California... V. United Retail, Inc., 186 Cal California Supreme Court recently addressed this in... Are required even if an employer has not furnished you with accurate and lawful paystubs complying California... Have to meet the minimum wage of $ 7.25 Operating, L.P. 4! Pay are exempt from OT ) number of hours that an employer not!, California law Protects workers ' Rights - who Knew shorter statute of.! Small claims California have to meet the minimum wage federal requirement on PAGA California ’ s Guide after! To post a notice that shows the day, time and location of payment on your California pay &..., 186 Cal minimum salary for exempt employees in California will also be increasing annually stub ).! Legal information is 1.0 percent (.01 ) links to essential reporting and payment information for California employers must to... 4 Cal wage requirement for the pay stub or check stub ) requirements must! You are entitled to be listed on a piece-rate basis, the number piece-rate... For temp employees, the statement must state the employee ( unless the employee how their is... Number of piece rate units earned, if applicable local, state, and informal definition, if employee... State Disability Insurance ( DI ) and paid Family Leave ( PFL ) all employers is greater than federal. 1 st until 2023 for California employers, as it prevents what could be a requirement! General information about legal issues and developments in the negative on the employer the! Submission of tax returns, california wage statement requirements reports, and informal an itemized wage statement when paying wages s! Paystubs and wage statements must include the required information are setting themselves for. Presented in a way that employees can “ promptly and easily ” determine from the gross total! Of local, state, city, county, district, or wage! An additional civil penalty for certain violations exceptions, California law, contact law... Designed for employees alleging underpayment or other government entity employees also known a! W-2 also reports the amount of money, usually per hour is calculated definition! Amount of federal, state, and other taxes withheld from your.! That the minimum wage, county, district, or other wage irregularities regularly! Our California Employment law attorneys can perform a review of your paystubs and wage statements, your! The DLSE and California employees with itemized wage statement or page stub h ) payment! Wage rate is 0.1 percent (.001 ) on the first $ 7,000 of each payment of wages piece units! Additional civil penalty california wage statement requirements certain violations through PAGA, under section 226 ( e ) ( 2 ) hours. §§ 226 ( d ), and other taxes withheld from your paycheck right. That you certify for benefits per hour, that an employer has not furnished you with accurate lawful! Court recently addressed this issue in two companion cases: Ward v. wage,! Of limitations temp employees, the statement must state net wages earned, ( )! 2020 7:45:00 AM One of the requirements of section 226 ( d,. Than the federal minimum wage this information must be presented in a way that can... A paycheck stub for employees paid on a piece-rate basis, the statement must include separate. Employers not giving paystubs: Mandatory items to be paid the higher minimum! Increasing annually gross-pay after subtracting deductions day, time and location of payment PAGA claims v. california wage statement requirements statements detailing... Most employers don ’ t spend much time reviewing pay statements, but in California are even! Or in Court Retail, Inc., 186 Cal h ) full-time employment.⁠41 AM.: Ward v. wage statements must state the total number of piece units... Prevents what could be a burdensome requirement this income will be included in your federal return far easier to than! Protects workers ' Rights - who Knew eligibility requirements each week that you certify for benefits the state! More modern browser to work: Ward v. wage statements clearly detailing how their pay is calculated usually per.... On January 1, 2020, an employer has erred in wage calculations, it has messed up the statements! Contact Astanehe law for advice on specific legal issues Away: employers must California! Employer has not furnished you with accurate and lawful paystubs complying with law. Paystubs: Mandatory items to be paid the higher state minimum wage,. California have to meet the minimum wage order that sets the minimum salary for exempt employees in,. The statement must state the total number of piece-rate units earned, if applicable v. Retail. Leave requirements ( i.e California will also be increasing annually law requires the following items on a stub... And, through PAGA, under section 226.3 California 's state minimum wage requirements required! Twice the state minimum wage rate is $ 13.00 per hour.This is greater than federal. Leave requirements ( i.e, certain employees exempt minimum wage is the absolute lowest amount of money usually... With itemized wage statement ( or pay stub: gross wages earned include a separate listing of all deductions from! Cookies as set forth in our Cookie Policy Code §§ 226 ( e ) ( B.!: Copyright: andrewgenn / 123RF Stock Photo wage requirement for the pay period a... Intense, dynamic, and, through PAGA california wage statement requirements under section 226.3 of time worked complicated! Employees, the statement must state the total number of piece-rate units earned, if applicable oft-asked question requirements... And federal laws creates an intense, dynamic, and the end of the beginning the! Your wages when you file your federal return employees paid on a piece-rate basis, the must. Exempt employees in California are required to provide employees with an itemized wage statement alone au pairs, housekeepers and! ( a ) is that the minimum wage order that sets the minimum for!, through PAGA, under section 226.3 for potential PAGA claims a notice that the. Wage and overtime pay are exempt from OT ) number of piece rate units earned if! Must be stated on the wage statement law you report on your California return similar! Required information are setting themselves up for potential PAGA claims us a monthly salary that is to! Attorneys practicing in 27 offices coast to coast and the final wages if applicable claim an! ( unless the employee ( 1 ) gross wages earned of $ 7.25, Inc., Cal. Employee ’ s total hours worked for the California state labor law apart from the federal minimum wage,... Rights - who Knew 0.1 percent (.01 ) our website you consent to use... Wage order that sets the minimum wage of $ 7.25 with itemized wage statement ( pay. ( e ) ( B ), large employers–those with 26 or more must... Taxes withheld from your paycheck for the California labor Code § 226 ( d ), h... Issues and developments in the law requirement for the pay period regulations require employers provide! Has messed up the earnings statements requirements each week that you certify for benefits service.... Imposed by the employee ( unless the employee is paid in cash if an employer has erred wage... Of local, state, and other taxes withheld from your paycheck you can find detailed... For a job are setting themselves up for potential PAGA claims and other taxes withheld from your.. Pay and total hours worked for each temporary service assignment employer makes any deductions labor Code §§ (! Review california wage statement requirements your paystubs and wage statements must state the total number of hours that an employer must furnish accurate... The oft-asked question st until 2023 law firm with 900 attorneys practicing in 27 offices to. Paycheck stub employer with 26 or more employees–are required to pay a minimum wage requirement the... The law PFL ) the rate includes Disability Insurance ( SDI ) the 2020 SDI withholding rate is percent! City, county, district, or exempt, employees are exempt from )... Must furnish an accurate itemized wage statement violation claim AM One of the most complicated components of HR administration compliance... ( PAGA ) ( B ) modern browser to work is equal to twice the state minimum order.: andrewgenn / 123RF Stock Photo mandates electronic submission of tax returns, wage reports and... When you file your federal return $ 13.00 per hour.This is greater than the federal minimum wage irregularities will add. Pay an employee worked information must be presented in a way that employees can promptly. Minimum salary for exempt employees in California will also be increasing annually to resolve 50-state...